Citys best buy so far
mancityforum.co.uk
Home      Members   Calendar   Who's On
Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
      


««12345»»»

Citys best buy so farExpand / Collapse
Who has been the best signing of the year?
Poll ResultsVotes
Elano
 
53.7%
29
Petrov
 
20.37%
11
Corluka
 
24.07%
13
Garrido
 
1.85%
1
Bianchi
0%
0
Gelson
0%
0
Geo
0%
0
0%
0
Member Votes: 54, Anonymous Votes: 0. You don't have permission to vote within this poll.
Author
Message
Posted 27/11/2007 09:38:05


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 07/05/2008 13:07:38
Posts: 1,131, Visits: 7,244
Gone for Elano but every one of them are very good footballers and very comfortable on the ball. You never get a feeling of panic when any of them get the ball. Class.
Post #130660
Posted 27/11/2007 13:07:01


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 02/05/2008 13:46:18
Posts: 4,517, Visits: 2,022
I dont think there is a bad one in there to be honest, even Bianchi has the potential to be a fantastic buy, if he keeps fit and his attitude right.

Petrov has also been very good for me, I think he is underated a little in the light of Elano. Corluka gets better every game and I wonder if he would be even better in the center.

Feliz Año Neuvo

Post #130750
Posted 27/11/2007 13:41:43


Second Division Poster

Second Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division PosterSecond Division Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 04/05/2008 13:15:13
Posts: 259, Visits: 484
For me it's a dead heat between Corluka & Elano. I also think that Fernandes has done extremley well what i've seen of him, defo one for the future.
Post #130795
Posted 27/11/2007 21:47:44


Championship Poster

Championship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 03/05/2008 06:21:15
Posts: 752, Visits: 1,454
Great question, because there really is no wrong answer. I've gone for Elano because he has that "it"  factor, despite the fact no one knew until he arrived. I love Petrov and Corluka as well, so won't argue with anyone who went for them.
Post #131146
Posted 27/11/2007 21:50:07


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 14/08/2008 15:57:17
Posts: 10,675, Visits: 4,891
I don't think Garrido's done a lot wrong, and pound for pound is an excellent signing.  It's just so easy to vote for Elano...

-------------------
up, charm, top, down, strange, bottom
Post #131149
Posted 27/11/2007 21:51:23


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 26/06/2008 07:48:03
Posts: 7,231, Visits: 6,694
Benny the Blue (27/11/2007)
I don't think Garrido's done a lot wrong, and pound for pound is an excellent signing. It's just so easy to vote for Elano...


True. He's had one off day and unfortunately it was against Chelsea.



you know, you know, if a feller named Monroe never fathered bluegrass
he would still be unrecognised as the grand wizard of speed metal


Post #131151
Posted 27/11/2007 21:52:34


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 14/08/2008 15:57:17
Posts: 10,675, Visits: 4,891
Mr Badger (27/11/2007)
Benny the Blue (27/11/2007)
I don't think Garrido's done a lot wrong, and pound for pound is an excellent signing. It's just so easy to vote for Elano...


True. He's had one off day and unfortunately it was against Chelsea.

Yup, and while he was very bad, he certainly wasn't the only one.  Prem left back for £1.5M is good business...

-------------------
up, charm, top, down, strange, bottom

Post #131152
Posted 28/11/2007 14:33:09
Non League Poster

Non League PosterNon League PosterNon League PosterNon League PosterNon League PosterNon League PosterNon League PosterNon League Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 10/01/2008 01:48:54
Posts: 9, Visits: 44
Elano is great but there are better players on his position. It's just that most of them don't play in Prem

So best buy should be Corluca. How often do you see a 21-year old defender playing that well? Sergio Ramos is the only other name I can think of.
Post #131365
Posted 28/11/2007 16:08:10


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 23/04/2008 17:16:41
Posts: 3,491, Visits: 7,132
TiDavid Lee Roth (27/11/2007)
As much as I heart Elano, I've gone for Corluka.  He's a class player already and he's only 21 so has a good 15 years at the top left yet.  A wise investment.

Yes. Yes this is what I think too.



It's practically Christmas today!
Post #131456
Posted 28/11/2007 16:12:31


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster