Citys best buy so far
mancityforum.co.uk
Home      Members   Calendar   Who's On
Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
      


12345»»»

Citys best buy so farExpand / Collapse
Who has been the best signing of the year?
Poll ResultsVotes
Elano
 
53.7%
29
Petrov
 
20.37%
11
Corluka
 
24.07%
13
Garrido
 
1.85%
1
Bianchi
0%
0
Gelson
0%
0
Geo
0%
0
0%
0
Member Votes: 54, Anonymous Votes: 0. You don't have permission to vote within this poll.
Author
Message
Posted 27/11/2007 01:12:22


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 03/05/2008 00:46:41
Posts: 1,630, Visits: 2,747
Ok bearing in mind what we paid for the player who has been the best signing so far, alot of people will say elano but considering we got petrov for half of what we paid for elano, surely he would have to be up there for "Best buy of the year" and corluka has been a rock at the back, and we got geo for nothing so will be interesting to see who gets the nod.



Sabrina, don't just stare at it, eat it
Post #130626
Posted 27/11/2007 04:18:46


Championship Poster

Championship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship PosterChampionship Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 02/03/2008 04:35:00
Posts: 523, Visits: 1,128
Corluka for me.

 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"I'm wavin' automatic guns at nuns."

Post #130628
Posted 27/11/2007 07:39:56


Cloudy's back

Cloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's backCloudy's back

Group: Moderators
Last Login: 22/07/2008 18:04:58
Posts: 7,484, Visits: 7,937
Gone for Elano although Bojinov should be on the list as well. I know we haven't seen much of him but I still have a very good feeling about him.

I'd probably argue that Sven has been our "best buy" as all the players he's bought in have improved the team but most importantly he's shown the inherited squad how to play football.



Avoid, rather than check. Check, rather than hurt. Hurt, rather than maim. Maim, rather than kill. For all life is precious, nor can any be replaced.
Post #130629
Posted 27/11/2007 08:54:48


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 09/05/2008 10:13:32
Posts: 8,322, Visits: 4,487
As much as I heart Elano, I've gone for Corluka.  He's a class player already and he's only 21 so has a good 15 years at the top left yet.  A wise investment.

___________________________________________________________________


I'm not an alcoholic, I'm a drunk. Alcoholics go to meetings.




Post #130634
Posted 27/11/2007 09:02:04


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 02/05/2008 20:29:16
Posts: 5,898, Visits: 5,427
It's great that this was a tough choice, but for me Elano edged it as I have had unfamiliar and wrong feeelings in my tummy every time I see him.

_________________________________________________________________________________

~ Listen to the tales and romanticise, how we follow the path of the hero.
Post #130635
Posted 27/11/2007 09:06:49


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 03/09/2008 15:53:17
Posts: 1,622, Visits: 1,231
Corluka for me.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Post #130638
Posted 27/11/2007 09:10:44


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 02/05/2008 20:29:16
Posts: 5,898, Visits: 5,427
Corluka does have great touch for a big fella. He must be 6'2 or 6'3 and he seems to be able to turn strikers and wingers inside out for fun.

_________________________________________________________________________________

~ Listen to the tales and romanticise, how we follow the path of the hero.
Post #130641
Posted 27/11/2007 09:15:32


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 08/08/2008 19:42:53
Posts: 5,303, Visits: 3,668
I think Corluka's 6'5" isn't he?

I don't want to vote, its a tough one choosing between the three of them, but Elano probably just nicks it, because so much of our attacking play has gone through him.

________________________________

Predicting false dawns since August '07.

Post #130645
Posted 27/11/2007 09:15:50


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster

Group: Moderators
Last Login: 30/09/2008 23:50:17
Posts: 10,619, Visits: 6,236
Elano. Has given us that bit of class on the ball that we haven't had since Ali B. Corluka runs him a very close second.

IMO it's easier to vote for Svens worst signing as they've more or less all been good, or have the potential to be good. I suspect Rolando would 'win', but he's not really had the opportunities.


Si thi tha nos
Post #130646
Posted 27/11/2007 09:27:31


Premiership Poster

Premiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership PosterPremiership Poster